And Never Let Her Go (2001) - Rotten Tomatoes

And Never Let Her Go2001

And Never Let Her Go (2001)





Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

And Never Let Her Go Photos

Movie Info

Based on a true crime story, the two-part TV movie And Never Let Her Go recounts the disappearance of Anne Marie Fahey in June of 1996, and the subsequent arrest and conviction of her accused murderer. Hired as a secretary by powerful Delaware attorney and gubernatorial aide, Thomas Capano (Mark Harmon), Anne Marie enters into a torrid and ofttimes abusive affair with her kinky boss. When Anne Marie's relatives report that she is missing, the governor of Delaware solicits the aid of the U.S. Department of Justice to solve the case. Although detective Frank Gugliatta (Paul Michael Glaser) and assistant U.S. attorney Colm Connolly (Steve Eckholdt) suspect that Capano has done away with Anne Marie, they are stymied by a lack of tangible proof...notably, the girl's body. It is not until Anne Marie's diary turns up in a most unexpected manner that Gugliatta and Connolly are able to fully act upon their suspicions -- and even then, the ultimate solution rests with the cooperation (or lack of same) of Capano's brother, Gerry (David Hewlett). Oscar winner Olympia Dukakis appears as Thomas Capano's formidable mother. Filmed in Toronto and told largely in flashback, And Never Let Her Go was originally telecast by CBS on April 1 and 4, 2001.


Mark Harmon
as Thomas Capano
Kathryn Morris
as Anne Marie Fahey
Rachel Ward
as Christine Sheve
Paul Michael Glaser
as Det. Frank Gugliatta
Steven Eckholdt
as Colm Connolly
Olympia Dukakis
as Marguerite Capano
Rebecca Jenkins
as Kathleen Fahey-Hosey
Rick Roberts
as Daniel Chapman
David Hewlett
as Gerry Capano
John Furey
as Louis Capano
Kevin Hicks
as Brian Fahey
Marcia Bennett
as Ruth Boylan
John Bourgeois
as David Stanton
Kim Bourne
as Tom's Secretary
Madeleine Butler
as Tom Capano's Daughter
Laura Catalano
as Michelle Capano
Amanda Hancox
as Kay Capano
Philip Craig
as Jim Tough
Gene Dinovi
as Father Donato
Michele Duquet
as Kelly Stevens
Allegra Fulton
as Eleanor Blanchard
Robert Haley
as Dr. Connor
Kevin Hare
as Patrick Hosey
David Huband
as Michael Longwill
Tammy Isbell
as Molly Marcer
Lawrence King
as Sam Leone
James Millington
as Mike Demski
Maria Ricossa
as Gina Caggiano
Robin Ward
as Gov. Carper
Tracy Waterhouse
as Ann Connolly
Jonathan Whittaker
as Kevin Freel
View All

Critic Reviews for And Never Let Her Go

All Critics (2) | Top Critics (2)

It seems strange that this riveting case would result in a miniseries in which the drama feels manufactured.

October 19, 2018 | Full Review…
Top Critic

... a by-the-numbers miniseries docudrama...

February 5, 2018 | Full Review…

Audience Reviews for And Never Let Her Go


A little too long, but a good telling of the story, which I didn't know about until seeing this movie.

Erin Collins
Erin Collins

Super Reviewer

And Never Let Her Go Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

News & Features