Another Thin Man (1939) - Rotten Tomatoes

Another Thin Man1939

Another Thin Man (1939)




Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

Another Thin Man Photos

Movie Info

Three years after the second Thin Man entry, MGM brought back the property by popular demand with Another Thin Man. As ever, William Powell and Myrna Loy star as sophisticated sleuths Nick and Nora Charles, with the added filip of 8-month-old Nick Charles Jr. At the invitation of munitions manufacturer Colonel MacFay (C. Aubrey Smith), the Charleses spend a weekend at MacFay's Long Island estate. The Colonel is certain that his shady ex-business associate Phil Church (Sheldon Leonard) plans to do him harm, a prognostication that apparently comes true when murder rears its ugly head. Though he's promised to cut down on his drinking (after all, he's a daddy now), Nick spends an inordinate amount of time sorting out the clues and identifying the actual murderer-who, of course, is the least likely suspect (and in fact is played by an actor who seldom if ever harmed a fly in any other film). Adding to the merry mayhem is the Charleses' efforts to find a good baby-sitter, resulting in an onslaught of "help"-and additional babies!--courtesy of Nick's old Underworld cronies. ~ Hal Erickson, Rovi

Watch it now


William Powell
as Nick Charles
Myrna Loy
as Nora Charles
Virginia Grey
as Lois MacFay/Linda Mills
Otto Kruger
as Assistant DA Van Slack
C. Aubrey Smith
as Col. Burr MacFay
Ruth Hussey
as Dorothy Waters
Nat Pendleton
as Lt. Guild
Patric Knowles
as Dudley Horn
Tom Neal
as Freddie Coleman
Phyllis Gordon
as Mrs. Bellam
Sheldon Leonard
as Phil Church
Don Costello
as Diamond Back Vogel
Harry Bellaver
as Creeps Binder
William A. Poulsen
as Nicky Charles Jr.
Marjorie Main
as Mrs. Dolley
Ralph Dunn
as Expressman
Horace MacMahon
as Chauffeur
Doodles Weaver
as Gatekeeper
George Guhl
as Bodyguard
Joe Devlin
as Bodyguard
Paul E. Burns
as Ticket Agent
Dick Elliott
as Detective
Edward Gargan
as Detective
William Tannen
as State Trooper
Milton Kibbee
as Les the Deputy
Horace McMahon
as MacFay's Chauffeur
Nestor Paiva
as Headwaiter
John Kelly
as Father
Paul Newlan
as Bodyguard
Edward Hearn
as Detective
Bert Roach
as Cookie the Drinker
Asta the Dog
as Himself
View All

News & Interviews for Another Thin Man

Critic Reviews for Another Thin Man

All Critics (20) | Top Critics (4)

Perhaps it is best to enjoy the detail without making too much effort to follow the plot, and certainly without any attempt to spot the murderer or to follow the logic of the detective's search for him. This detail is often very entertaining.

October 16, 2020 | Full Review…

We're still appreciative, but we found too many chestnuts in the dressing.

January 28, 2006 | Rating: 3/5 | Full Review…

This 1939 release is still watchable, though the spirit is now sitcom.

January 1, 2000 | Full Review…

William Powell and Myrna Loy are a delight as always, even if their repartee doesn't feel quite as witty as in the previous two films, and they make the most of what they're given.

May 4, 2021 | Rating: 2.5/4 | Full Review…

As in the first two films, the labyrinthine mystery holds together.

April 30, 2021 | Rating: 3.5/4 | Full Review…

The atmosphere and sets, along with stellar performances by the principals, can't offset a weak story.

August 7, 2012 | Rating: 3/4 | Full Review…

Audience Reviews for Another Thin Man

The third installment in the series, and made after William Powell's bought with cancer and loss of Jean Harlow, 'Another Thin Man' doesn't miss a beat. Much is made of Powell and Myrna Loy's on-screen chemistry, and it's deserved. While figuring out whodunit, Powell is cool, calm, and bemused, and Loy is spunky and brave. They both have such a natural playfulness about them, and in addition to comic relief from their dog Asta, they have a one year old baby in this movie. I also absolutely loved the dancing we see in the 'West Indies Club' towards the end, by the (uncredited) René Rivero Guillen and Ramona Ajon (stage names René & Estela) - look for the clip on youtube, and you'll see what I mean, it's silky smooth and fantastic.

Antonius Block
Antonius Block

Super Reviewer

Although the Thin Man movies get more predictable as the series goes on, the third movie is still a good movie, it's very funny.

Aj V
Aj V

Super Reviewer


The third in the Thin Man series also comes up third in quality. Nick and Nora go out to Long Island to visit the manager of Nora's father's finances, because he's worried about a former employees threats. Former employee Phil Church (Sheldon Leonard) claims that if he dreams about a person 3 times, that person winds up dead. Sure enough, the old man winds up dead, and it's Church who is the prime suspect. Things only get more convoluted from here, as the detectives hunt down Church and his gang. If you've seen the previous two Thin Man movies, it's fairly easy to spot the murderer early on, as a formula seems to be developing. They also seem to be running out of gags to do with the dog, Asta. At one point, and for no apparent reason, the dog does a backwards flip while walking towards the stairs, in what appears to be cuteness for cuteness' sake. Speaking of cuteness for cuteness' sake, a baby has been added to Nick and Nora's life, although it plays a very minor role in the proceedings (just at the end). There's still some great dialogue here, though I find it odd when characters who appear to be good, are suddenly found out to be bad, and their manner of speaking changes from erudite to bowery in a matter of seconds. Very odd indeed, see. If youz mugs are in da mood fer a old-fashioned "who-done-it?", you'd best stick wit the foist two movies, see. But if youz arredy seen em, and ya needz yer fix o' flatfeets and gumheels, with hot petunias and dames wit heaters under their jalopies, i guess dis is bettah dan nuttin.

Devon Bott
Devon Bott

Super Reviewer

Another Thin Man Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

News & Features