The Idolmaker (1980) - Rotten Tomatoes

The Idolmaker1980

The Idolmaker (1980)




Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

The Idolmaker Photos

Movie Info

The story of Philadelphia-based rock 'n' roll starmaker Bob Marcucci is given a pointed a clef treatment in The Idolmaker. Ray Sharkey plays Vincent Vacarri, who takes a couple of raw young kids (Peter Gallagher and Paul Land) and molds them into teen idols. If Gallagher and Land seem at times to be clones of Fabian and Frankie Avalon, then you've gotten the point. As played by Sharkey, Vacarri comes off as both maven and monster: he gives his boys everything they need professionally and everything they want personally, but it's subliminally clear that his interest is purely mercenary (incredibly, Bob Marcucci is the film's technical advisor). An excellent, clear-eyed view of show biz mechanics, The Idolmaker falters only in its anachronisms, notably the style of music performed by Vacarri's proteges.

Watch it now


Ray Sharkey
as Vincent Vacarri
Tovah Feldshuh
as Brenda Roberts
Paul Land
as Tommy Dee
Joe Pantoliano
as Gino Pilato
Maureen McCormick
as Ellen Fields
John Aprea
as Paul Vacarri
Richard Bright
as Uncle Tony
Olympia Dukakis
as Mrs. Vacarri
Deney Terrio
as Jerry Martin
Denny Terrio
as Jerry Martin
Kenneth W. O'Brien
as Walt Bennett
London Fog
as (As London Fog)
View All

Critic Reviews for The Idolmaker

All Critics (9) | Top Critics (2)

The movie's two main aims -- to blow the lid off the music business and to exalt some of the unsung heroes of American pop culture -- are somewhat contradictory, and haven't been worked into a polished narrative.

August 27, 2013 | Rating: 3/5 | Full Review…

At the core of The Idolmaker, making it a better film than it might otherwise have been, is the hungry, lonely ego of the movie's hero, Vince Vacarri.

October 23, 2004 | Rating: 3/4 | Full Review…

Part of the reason why The Idolmaker is as compelling as it is comes from Ray Sharkey's performance as Vinnie.

July 19, 2019 | Full Review…

Taylor Hackford showed his skills as a commercial director with his very first picture.

July 31, 2011 | Rating: B- | Full Review…

Audience Reviews for The Idolmaker

An enjoyable look back at the Italian-American teen idol singers of the 50's and early 60's. The performance by Ray Starkey (super underrated actor) makes this a fun film to see. Peter Gallagher did a fantastic job as a teen idol, too. Not a blockbuster film, but I found this movie very entertaining...

Cynthia S.
Cynthia S.

Super Reviewer

A music manager creates a star out of a singer, but after they part, he has to start all over with a busboy. Some of the film is stylish, but there's nothing new about this story. Even though The Idolmaker predates mediocre films That Thing You Do and Cadillac Records, I can't imagine that 1980 had not seen the rise and fall of a music manager storyline before. Regardless of its lack of originality, what bothers me most about the film is the main character's hotheadedness and its depiction of women. Vincent is a New York street tough, and he screams and yells at the drop of a hat. Yes, I've met people like Vincent, but there are no layers to his character or to Ray Sharkey's performance. He schemes and he yells, and that's about the extent of it. Women in The Idolmaker are either part of a massive throng of screaming prepubescents or supporting characters who serve the male main characters as verbal punching bags or sex partners or both. They may have interested of their own, as is the case with Ellen, but these interests are either easily manipulated or subsumed to male will. Overall, this film is a cliche with no noteworthy songs and a sexist portrayal of women.

Jim Hunter
Jim Hunter

Super Reviewer

I thought it was pretty cool. The songs were decent and I enjoyied watching such a driven character. My only gripe is that it ends in the "Hollywood" way.

Marion Ravenwood
Marion Ravenwood

Super Reviewer

The Idolmaker Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

News & Features