Loving Annabelle (2006) - Rotten Tomatoes

Loving Annabelle2006

Loving Annabelle (2006)





Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

Loving Annabelle Photos

Movie Info

Writer/director Katherine Brooks adapts the classic lesbian drama Mädchen in Uniform with this tale of a precocious senator's daughter and Catholic boarding school student who falls desperately in love with her beautiful poetry teacher. Simone Bradley (Diane Gaidry) is a teacher who finds peace within the walls of Saint Theresa's school, and purpose in bringing the wonders of poetry to her young female students. Though newly arrived student Annabelle (Erin Kelly) has notable intelligence and charisma to spare, her fiery disobedience finds the stern headmistress imploring Simone to reign in the young rebel. But Annabelle's insubordination is about to become the least of Simone's concerns, because when the advances of the passionate young woman reveal her teacher's innermost desires, the devoted teacher will be forced to choose between her career and an affair that could quite possibly destroy her livelihood.

Watch it now


Erin Kelly
as Annabelle
Ilene Graff
as Mother Emaculata
Kevin McCarthy
as Father Harris
John Farley
as Detective
Gustine Fudickar
as Cat Pegrum
Stephen Rue
as Friend's Father
Wendy Schaal
as Senator Tillman
Karen Teliha
as Sister Clair
View All

Critic Reviews for Loving Annabelle

All Critics (3)

In spite of the premise that reads more like a "Penthouse" letter, Brooks' controversial romance is much more heart felt and complex in examining both of its characters and their intentions toward one another...

August 9, 2007 | Rating: 3/5

If you're looking for a bare-bones story about girl-on-woman love that goes precisely where you're expecting it to go, you could do worse.

February 9, 2007 | Rating: 2.5/5 | Full Review…

almost criminal in its lack of a third act.

February 7, 2007 | Rating: 2.5/5

Audience Reviews for Loving Annabelle


If you like movies that feature relationships, Loving Annabelle fits the bill. Of course the problem is that no matter how much anyone is in love, it is just not possible to act on your feelings if you are the teacher, and the object of your affections is your student. Many of the other reviews complain about the 'abrupt' ending, but it suits the movie.

Red Lats
Red Lats

Super Reviewer


This is the story of a young lady who was sent to a private catholic school by her mother, who's a Senator. There she feels out of place, but finds comfort with her teacher, Simone. Their intensity grows throughout the school year to where one night everything changes. It was a decent love story to watch, but didn't bring much for me. I also didn't really like the ending....it ended so abruptly.

Nani Vang
Nani Vang

Super Reviewer


Not that good. Can't understand how this is rating quite highly on here. The acting and story is like a bad porn film, and the topic is a bit icky. I have no problem at all watching a movie aimed at, or featuring gay people, but it's a bit off when one is a teen girl and one's an older teacher. Yes, the teacher is reasonably sympathetic, and watching the making-of doco clarified what the director was trying to acheive, but it just does not work. Erin Kelly is just hard faced and comes across like a little trouble maker, do not buy her as being genuine in her feelings at all, even though she is clearly meant to be, and ditto to the other class mates, not even remotely convincing. Diane Gaidry comes out of it with a bit of dignity, but it's not saying much. There are much better movies out there if you're a fan of this genre, :"But I'm a cheerleader", "All over me", to name just a few...

Nicki Marie
Nicki Marie

Super Reviewer

Loving Annabelle Quotes

News & Features