My Favorite Wife (1940) - Rotten Tomatoes

My Favorite Wife1940

My Favorite Wife (1940)




Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

My Favorite Wife Photos

Movie Info

Leo McCarey was supposed to both produce and direct My Favorite Wife, but an illness forced him to relinquish the director's chair to Garson Kanin, who did a splendid job. This hilarious retread of the old "Enoch Arden" legend stars Irene Dunne as Ellen, who returns home to her husband Nick (Cary Grant) and children Tim (Ann Shoemaker) and Chinch (Mary Lou Harrington) after being marooned on a desert island for seven years. Thing of it is, Ellen has been declared legally dead, and Nick has taken unto himself a second wife, the bitchy Bianca (Gail Patrick). Upon discovering that Ellen is still alive, Nick is on the verge of a tender reunion-until it discovers that she spent those seven lost years in the company of handsome Mr. Barkett (Randolph Scott). The superb supporting cast includes Granville Bates as a flummoxed judge, Chester Clute as a meek shoe salesman whom Ellen tries to pass off as Barkett, and Donald MacBride as a beetle-browed honeymoon-hotel clerk. My Favorite Wife was remade in 1963 as Move Over Darling, in which Irene Dunne and Cary Grant were replaced by Doris Day and James Garner.

Watch it now


Irene Dunne
as Ellen Arden
Cary Grant
as Nick Arden
Randolph Scott
as Stephen Burkett
Scotty Beckett
as Tim Arden
Mary Lou Harrington
as Chinch Arden
Donald MacBride
as Hotel Clerk
Pedro de Cordoba
as Dr. Kohlmar
Brandon Tynan
as Dr. Manning
Harold Gerald
as Assistant Clerk
Murray Alper
as Bartender
Earle Hodgins
as Court Clerk
Cyril Ring
as Contestant
Horace McMahon
as Truck Driver
Jean Acker
as Witness
Harold Gerard
as Assistant Court Clerk
Frank Marlowe
as Photographer
Thelma Joel
as Miss Rosenthal
Horace MacMahon
as Truck Driver
Chester Clute
as Little Man
Earl Hodgins
as Clerk of Court
Cy Kendall
as Detective
Pat West
as Caretaker
View All

Critic Reviews for My Favorite Wife

All Critics (13) | Top Critics (4)

Ninety minutes of delightfully irrational comedy.

December 8, 2008 | Full Review…
Top Critic

A relatively formulaic (though beautifully produced) bedroom comedy...

June 24, 2006 | Full Review…
Top Critic

The direction of Garson Kanin is spotty, and there is evidence of faults in editing -- but who cares?

March 25, 2006 | Full Review…

While it's pleasant enough, the freshness is definitely off the bloom.

February 27, 2001 | Full Review…

Garson Kanin is not Leo McCarey, who was originally assigned to direct this screwball comedy, reuniting Cary Grant and Irene Dunne (Awful Truth), but he has made a well acted, decent, and enjoyable film.

January 8, 2012 | Rating: B | Full Review…

Nowadays, we would call this the purview of a low-rent TV sitcom. Watching it play out 70 years earlier with top-flight stars doesn't make it any more palatable.

January 10, 2011 | Rating: 2/5

Audience Reviews for My Favorite Wife

i liked this one better than "the awful truth" (a more popular, more well known film), although i don't know why...maybe it's simply the premise appeals to some wacked out sense of comedy i've got somewhere in my attic

Kevin M. Williams
Kevin M. Williams

Super Reviewer

My Favorite Wife is one of the lesser, lighter Cary Grant movies. In it, he plays a man whose wife is lost at sea. Seven years later, he goes to the judge to have her declared dead so that he may re-marry. No sooner does he re-marry when his first wife comes wandering back home. She had been living on a tropical island for the last seven years and had only been rescued recently by a passing freighter. Naturally, from this all sorts of chaos arises. Well, some minor chaos. This film is listed as a starring vehicle for Irene Dunne (the original wife), so it's little wonder the new wife (Gail Patrick) is barely in the picture at all. There's very little controversy or dilemma involved on the husband's part. He never considers the new wife, even for a little bit. There's a couple of cute gags, mostly involving the guy Dunne was stuck on the island with (Randolph Scott), but this film is way too slight to make anyone go out of their way to see it.

Devon Bott
Devon Bott

Super Reviewer

Dunne and Grant were teamed many a time, but this film seems a bit broader, and filled with moments where you have to suspend your disbelief, including Dunne's tragic circumstances, and Grant's state of marital contentedness. It's all lovey dovey and amazingly sweet, but it specifically works because the two compliment each other with their zany antics and wanton disregard for lack of wit and candor.

Spencer S.
Spencer S.

Super Reviewer

My Favorite Wife Quotes

News & Features