The Left Handed Gun (1958) - Rotten Tomatoes

The Left Handed Gun (1958)




Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

The Left Handed Gun Photos

Movie Info

Arthur Penn directed this quirky look at the legend of Billy the Kid (Paul Newman), which follows the outlaw from his days in the Lincoln County cattle wars through to his murder.

Watch it now


Paul Newman
as William 'Billy the Kid' Bonney
John Dehner
as Pat Garrett
Hurd Hatfield
as Moultrie
James Congdon
as Charlie Boudre
James Best
as Tom Folliard
John Dierkes
as McSween
Ainslie Pryor
as Joe Grant
Denver Pyle
as Ollinger
Nestor Paiva
as Maxwell
Jo Summers
as Mrs. Garrett
Anne Barton
as Mrs. Hill
View All

Critic Reviews for The Left Handed Gun

All Critics (10) | Top Critics (4)

Saddled with a pretentious and senseless screenplay about Billy the Kid, this lame oater drags all parties down with it.

January 9, 2018 | Full Review…

Penn's training in theater and live-TV drama (e.g. Playhouse 90) shows; the central performance is rehearsed into an anxious stir, every line matched to an actorly decision, a blocking cue.

November 12, 2008 | Full Review…

The picture is a smart and exciting western paced by Paul Newman's intense portrayal.

June 18, 2008 | Full Review…

Penn's first film, it is in many ways a key stage in the development of the Western.

October 21, 2006
Top Critic

Paul Newman portrays the cow-country Rebel Without a Cause, Billy the Kid, in a western which is crammed with slambang action. Its characters, however, remain shadowy to the end.

November 11, 2019 | Full Review…

To the part of Billy the Kid, he brings an air of moronic sensitivity that is very telling, very delinquent and disturbingly typical.

July 12, 2018 | Full Review…

Audience Reviews for The Left Handed Gun

Billy the Kid seeks revenge for the killing of a cattle rancher who showed him kindness. I've never found the Western genre that compelling. Sure, there are some Westerns that use the lawlessness of the place/era as a way to debate the formation of laws in some kind of modern Locke vs. Rousseau discussion, and there are others that are characters studies of a different sort. But overall, macho violence and loud action scenes usually dominate the genre, and I fail to connect to any of the characters. Aside from Paul Newman's performance, The Left Handed Gun is everything I don't like about Westerns. It's predictable, and Billy the Kid holds no great aura for me - he's a snide, hot-headed, illiterate fuck-up, and though he comes to realize this by the end, I have trouble understanding why he holds so much pull for people in general and filmmakers specifically. Within the context of the film, I don't see any motivation for a woman to sleep with him (in the lamest seduction sequence ever - "With you. With you. With you.") or for Garrett to take him under his wing. Overall, the film gets strong reviews from friends and reviewers alike, but there must be something I'm missing about this genre.

Jim Hunter
Jim Hunter

Super Reviewer

Any fan of the Young Guns movies that our generation grew up with should check this out. Obviously the production value was not as good and Hollywood license runs rampant with Gore Vidal's classic non-fiction. This movie was erroniously titled at a time when most historians mistakenly assumed that Billy the Kid was left handed based on a reversed image.

Sean Gillespie
Sean Gillespie

Super Reviewer


While this is one of the many inferior Billy the Kid stories, it still has Paul Newman as a bizarre and crazy version of the character. The movie mainly fails on the lack of scope and story, which is completely mind boggling to me. When it's a character like Billy the Kid, you have no excuse to tell a weak story. I'm assuming this also had a lower budget, so some things are excused. However, it should really only be seen for Paul Newman; nothing else

Conner Rainwater
Conner Rainwater

Super Reviewer

The Left Handed Gun Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

News & Features