Unforgettable: Season 1 - Rotten Tomatoes

Unforgettable: Season 1 (2011-2012)




Critic Consensus: More tedious than compelling, Unforgettable is yet another lukewarm procedural.


Unforgettable: Season 1 Photos

Tv Season Info

Poppy Montgomery stars as a detective with a flawless memory who works homicides and tries to solve her sister's murder from years before. After having quit the force, she reluctantly agrees to help her former boyfriend and partner, Lt. Al Burns (Dylan Walsh), with a case in Queens, and ends up rejoining the police. Despite her unique ability, she is unable to remember a day from her childhood when her sister was murdered, and is on a prolonged search for her killer. Assisting her in solving crimes is Dr. Joanne Webster (Jane Curtin), an acerbic medical examiner.


Poppy Montgomery
as Carrie Wells
Dylan Walsh
as Al Burns
Michael Gaston
as Mike Costello
Kevin Rankin
as Roe Saunders
Daya Vaidya
as Nina Inara
Jane Curtin
as Joanne Webster
Britt Lower
as Tanya Sitkowsky
James Urbaniak
as Richard Simmons
Victoria Leigh
as Young Carrie
Jackson Hurst
as Steve Cioffi Jr.
Omar Metwally
as Adam Gilroy
Elias Koteas
as Sam Rhodes
Matt Servitto
as Dan Marston
Annie Parisse
as Elaine Margulies
Tom Mason
as Pat Burns
Kyle Catlett
as Max Seiferth
Cotter Smith
as Jay Barrett
Marilu Henner
as Edie Tripp
Justin Adams
as Young Sam
Madison Arnold
as Saul Wanamaker
Ryan O'Nan
as Tom Martin
Sue Cremin
as Younger Alice
Sherri Saum
as Rosario Sanchez
Malachy Cleary
as Det. Jim Kelly
Nicole Brill
as Donnamarie Recco
Dallas Roberts
as Eliot Delson
Angela Christian
as Allison Forrest
Adam Trese
as Jay Krause
Linda Emond
as Debi Moser
Clark Carmichael
as Pierre-Henry
Scott Cohen
as Dr. Sam Barlow
Paul Fitzgerald
as Clancy Watts
Kevin O'Rourke
as Jack Feeney
Chris Beetem
as Duane Tate
Thomas Guiry
as Ken Harbert
Paul Urcioli
as Sydney Burrell
Olivia Flynn
as Young Carrie
Jennifer Ferrin
as Janine Barlow
Al Sapienza
as Joe Hagan
Laurence Blum
as Bob Jensen
Sofia Jean Gomez
as Catherine Grant
Caitlin O'Connell
as Edith Feeney
Anne Bates
as Allyson Tate
Brad Heberlee
as Gary Wright
Lenny Venito
as Det. Stan Moyer
Socorro Santiago
as Lorena Cruz
Victoria Cartagena
as Maria Ortiz
Drew Powell
as Kevin McMillan
Ismail Bashey
as Aziz Malik
Stu "Large" Riley
as Augie Security Guard
Maury Ginsberg
as Isaac Brezner
Omar Rodríguez
as Mario Cruz
Nick Sandow
as William "Bud" Spence
Mason Petit
as Arthur Greene
Jenny Mercein
as Reporter
Michael Arden
as Joe Williams
Alfredo Narciso
as Det. Richard Franco
Chris Bauer
as Dennis Halsey
Catherine Wolf
as Eleanor Stein
Olli Haaskivi
as Man Dressed as Morgan
Steve Cirbus
as Lou Nagle
Jose Soto
as Pablo Hortua
Stivi Paskoski
as Det. Anthony Cantone
Isidra Vega
as Tori Guerrero
Christopher McCann
as Thad Ralston
Albert Jones
as Ron Pappas
Ro Boddie
as Pizza Guy
Kate Skinner
as Judge Wilkinson
Charlie Hudson III
as Jerome 'J-Dog' Dixon
Arthur J. Nascarella
as Stefano Cioffi
Robert Turano
as Lou Kestler
Chance Kelly
as Alex Logan
Eden Marryshow
as Ramon Garza
Lesley Stahl
as Herself
Caris Vujcec
as CSU Investigator
Mike Houston
as Erik Newsome
James DiSalvatore
as Jerry Mason
Jordan Leeds
as Reginald Donner
Kevin O'Donnell
as Marshall Green
Ejyp Johnson
as LeShawn Doyle
Peter Van Wagner
as Saul Timkin
Adam McNulty
as Sgt. Patrick Woodson
Stephen Mailer
as Brett Langley
Danielle Skraastad
as Liza Newsome
John Sharian
as George Creller
Quinn McColgan
as Anna Halsey
Elain R. Graham
as Virginia White
Sarah Sokolovic
as Lauren Garber
Timothy Adams
as Steve Latman
Heidi Armbruster
as Sandra Smith
Frank Ridley
as Burly Man
Michael Basile
as Firefighter
Gary Basaraba
as Lt. Willard
Frank Page
as Bodyguard
James Waterston
as Ian Smith
David Costabile
as Dr. McCardle
Roxanna Hope
as Wendy Wilson
Chris Barnes
as NYFD Chief
Joseph Amato
as Miles Berkowitz
Che Ayende
as Dr. Raker
Brian O'Neill
as Frank Harbert
Frank Harts
as CSU Tech
Emma Ramos
as Snack Bar Cashier
Clem Cheung
as Neighbor
Wayne Maugans
as Dr. White
Omar Gonzalez
as Mr. Banico
Steven Rishard
as Tom Kunis
Frank Deal
as Surgeon
Ken Wong
as Cable Guy
View All

Critic Reviews for Unforgettable: Season 1

All Critics (20) | Top Critics (13)

Wait. I forgot. Oh yeah - no, not hooked on this generic-looking crime-solver.

September 20, 2011 | Rating: C | Full Review…

It's not a great series, but it looks to be a solidly commercial one.

September 20, 2011 | Rating: B- | Full Review…
Top Critic

Unforgettable has a ways to go, but it's got a lot of the right stuff.

September 20, 2011 | Rating: 4/5 | Full Review…

"Unforgettable" was on no one's list as one of the "buzzier" fall pilots, but that doesn't mean it's not one of the better ones. It is.

September 20, 2011 | Rating: A- | Full Review…
Top Critic

Illustrating the concept of hyperthymesia presents a challenge, because it requires a lot of replay of a scene in excruciating detail to prove that Carrie, But, it gets a bit tiresome, and the show is ultimately unmemorable.

October 22, 2018 | Full Review…

Unforgettable fails to do anything but deliver a run-of-the-mill cop show with a slight gimmick.

July 2, 2018 | Full Review…

Audience Reviews for Unforgettable: Season 1

There are no featured audience reviews yet. Click the link below to see what others say about Unforgettable: Season 1!

Discussion Forum

Discuss Unforgettable on our TV talk forum!

News & Features